Friday, May 23, 2008

Olbermann on Clinton's assassination comment (s)

There is just nothing better I could say.

Asked if her continuing fight for the nomination against Senator Obama hurts the Democratic party, Sen. Hillary Clinton replied, "I don't. Because again, I've been around long enough. You know, my husband did not wrap up the nomination in 1992 until he won the California primary somewhere in the middle of June, right? We all remember Bobby Kennedy was assassinated in June in California. You know, I just don't understand it. You know, there's lots of speculation about why it is. “
The comments were recorded and we showed them to you earlier and they are online as we speak.

She actually said those words.
Those words, Senator?
You actually invoked the nightmare of political assassination.
You actually invoked the specter of an inspirational leader, at the seeming moment of triumph, for himself and a battered nation yearning to breathe free, silenced forever.

You actually used the word "assassination" in the middle of a campaign with a loud undertone of racial hatred - and gender hatred - and political hatred.
You actually used the word "assassination" in a time when there is a fear, unspoken but vivid and terrible, that our again-troubled land and fractured political landscape might target a black man running for president.
Or a white man.
Or a white woman!
You actually used those words, in this America, Senator, while running against an African-American against whom the death threats started the moment he declared his campaign?

You actually used those words, in this America, Senator, while running to break your "greatest glass ceiling" and claiming there are people who would do anything to stop you?

You! Senator - never mind the implications of using the word "assassination" in any connection to Senator Obama...What about you? You cannot say this!
The references, said her spokesperson, were not, in any way, weighted.
The allusions, said Mo Uh-leathee, are, "...historical examples of the nominating process going well into the summer and any reading into it beyond that would be inaccurate and outrageous."
I'm sorry.
There is no inaccuracy.

Not for a moment does any rational person believe Senator Clinton is actually hoping for the worst of all political calamities.
Yet the outrage belongs, not to Senator Clinton or her supporters, but to every other American.

Firstly, she has previously bordered on the remarks she made today...
Then swerved back from them and the awful skid they represented.
She said, in an off-camera interview with Time on March 6, "Primary contests used to last a lot longer. We all remember the great tragedy of Bobby Kennedy being assassinated in June in L.A. My husband didn't wrap up the nomination in 1992 until June, also in California. Having a primary contest go through June is nothing particularly unusual. We will see how it unfolds as we go forward over the next three to four months."

In retrospect, we failed her when we did not call her out, for that remark, dry and only disturbing, in a magazine's pages. But somebody obviously warned her of the danger of that rhetoric:
After the Indiana primary, on May 7, she told supporters at a Washington hotel:
"Sometimes you gotta calm people down a little bit. But if you look at successful presidential campaigns, my husband did not get the nomination until June of 1992. I remember tragically when Senator Kennedy won California near the end of that process."

And at Shepherdstown, West Virginia, on the same day, she referenced it again:
"You know, I remember very well what happened in the California primary in 1968 as, you know, Senator Kennedy won that primary."
On March 6th she had said "assassinated."

By May 7 she had avoided it. Today... she went back to an awful well. There is no good time to recall the awful events of June 5th, 1968, of Senator Bobby Kennedy, happy and alive - perhaps, for the first time since his own brother's death in Dallas in 1963... Galvanized to try to lead this nation back from one of its darkest eras... Only to fall victim to the same surge that took that brother, and Martin Luther King... There is no good time to recall this. But certainly to invoke it, two weeks before the exact 40th anniversary of the assassination, is an insensitive and heartless thing.

And certainly to invoke it, three days after the awful diagnosis, and heart-breaking prognosis, for Senator Ted Kennedy, is just as insensitive, and just as heartless. And both actions, open a door wide into the soul of somebody who seeks the highest office in this country, and through that door shows something not merely troubling, but frightening. And politically inexplicable.

What, Senator, do you suppose would happen if you withdrew from the campaign, and Senator Obama formally became the presumptive nominee, and then suddenly left the scene? It doesn't even have to be the “dark curse upon the land” you mentioned today, Senator. Nor even an issue of health. He could simply change his mind... Or there could unfold that perfect-storm scandal your people have often referenced, even predicted. Maybe he could get a better offer from some other, wiser, country. What happens then, Senator? You are not allowed back into the race? Your delegates and your support vanish? The Democrats don't run anybody for President?

What happens, of course, is what happened when the Democrats' vice presidential choice, Senator Thomas Eagleton of Missouri, had to withdraw from the ticket, in 1972after it proved he had not been forthcoming about previous mental health treatments. George McGovern simply got another vice president.

The rest is after the break

Senator, as late as the late summer of 1864 the Republicans were talking about having a second convention, to withdraw Abraham Lincoln's re-nomination and choose somebody else because until Sherman took Atlanta in September it looked like Lincoln was going to lose to George McClellan.

You could theoretically suspend your campaign, Senator.

There's plenty of time and plenty of historical precedent, Senator, in case you want to come back in, if something bad should happen to Senator Obama. Nothing serious, mind you.

It's just like you said, "We all remember Bobby Kennedy was assassinated in June in California."

Since those awful words in Sioux Falls, and after the condescending, buck-passing statement from her spokesperson, Senator Clinton has made something akin to an apology, without any evident recognition of the true trauma she has inflicted.

"I was discussing the Democratic primary history, and in the course of that discussion mentioned the campaigns both my husband and Senator Kennedy waged California in June in 1992 and 1968," she said in Brandon, South Dakota. "I was referencing those to make the point that we have had nomination primary contests that go into June. That's a historic fact.

"The Kennedys have been much on my mind the last days because of Senator Kennedy. I regret that if my referencing that moment of trauma for our entire nation, particularly for the Kennedy family was in any way offensive, I certainly had no intention of that whatsoever."

"My view is that we have to look to the past and to our leaders who have inspired us and give us a lot to live up to and I'm honored to hold Senator Kennedy's seat in the United States Senate in the state of New York and have the highest regard for the entire Kennedy family. Thanks. Not a word about the inappropriateness of referencing assassination.

Not a word about the inappropriateness of implying - whether it was intended or not - that she was hanging around waiting for somebody to try something terrible.

Not a word about Senator Obama.

Not a word about Senator McCain.

Not: I'm sorry...

Not: I apologize...

Not: I blew it...

Not: please forgive me.

God knows, Senator, in this campaign, this nation has had to forgive you, early and often...

And despite your now traditional position of the offended victim, the nation has forgiven you.

We have forgiven you your insistence that there have been widespread calls for you to end your campaign, when such calls had been few. We have forgiven you your misspeaking about Martin Luther King's relative importance to the Civil Rights movement.

We have forgiven you your misspeaking about your under-fire landing in Bosnia.

We have forgiven you insisting Michigan's vote wouldn't count and then claiming those who would not count it were Un-Democratic.

We have forgiven you pledging to not campaign in Florida and thus disenfranchise voters there, and then claim those who stuck to those rules were as wrong as those who defended slavery or denied women the vote.

We have forgiven you the photos of Osama Bin Laden in an anti-Obama ad...

We have forgiven you fawning over the fairness of Fox News while they were still calling you a murderer.

We have forgiven you accepting Richard Mellon Scaife's endorsement and then laughing as you described his "deathbed conversion."

We have forgiven you quoting the electoral predictions of Boss Karl Rove.

We have forgiven you the 3 a.m. Phone Call commercial.

We have forgiven you President Clinton's disparaging comparison of the Obama candidacy to Jesse Jackson's.

We have forgiven you Geraldine Ferraro's national radio interview suggesting Obama would not still be in the race had he been a white man.

We have forgiven you the dozen changing metrics and the endless self-contradictions of your insistence that your nomination is mathematically probable rather than a statistical impossibility.

We have forgiven you your declaration of some primary states as counting and some as not.

We have forgiven you exploiting Jeremiah Wright in front of the editorial board of the lunatic-fringe Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

We have forgiven you exploiting William Ayers in front of the debate on ABC.

We have forgiven you for boasting of your "support among working, hard-working Americans, white Americans"...

We have even forgiven you repeatedly praising Senator McCain at Senator Obama's expense, and your own expense, and the Democratic ticket's expense.

But Senator, we cannot forgive you this.

"You know, my husband did not wrap up the nomination in 1992 until he won the California primary somewhere in the middle of June, right? We all remember Bobby Kennedy was assassinated in June in California."

We cannot forgive you this -- not because it is crass and low and unfeeling and brutal.

This is unforgivable, because this nation's deepest shame, its most enduring horror, its most terrifying legacy, is political assassination.





Martin Luther King.

Robert Kennedy.

And, but for the grace of the universe or the luck of the draw, Reagan, Ford, Truman, Nixon, Andrew Jackson, both Roosevelts, even George Wallace.

The politics of this nation is steeped enough in blood, Senator Clinton, you cannot and must not invoke that imagery! Anywhere! At any time!

And to not appreciate, immediately - to still not appreciate tonight - just what you have done... is to reveal an incomprehension of the America you seek to lead.

This, Senator, is too much.

Because a senator - a politician - a person - who can let hang in mid-air the prospect that she might just be sticking around in part, just in case the other guy gets shot - has no business being, and no capacity to be, the President of the United States.

Good night and good luck.



Therapy Cat said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Therapy Cat said...

Being well-behaved is over-rated. On Tuesday, Barack went over the hump. Referencing RFK's assassination as if it were just a date in June was over-the-top. Hillary's run is over.

Over and out.

Susan said...

Lest we forget: Malcolm X, the students at Kent State, Medgar Evers, and the 4 civil rights students who were murdered in the south in the 60s. Just for the record. I expect there were more from that terrible time in our history, and I've forgotten.

What we must hold in our hearts: no matter what happens from here on out, we will regain our democracy, take back our hope, reclaim our own local destiny, protect our nation and our planet. Yes, we can!

Therapy Cat said...

In addition to engaging in wordplay with questionable skill, tonight I'm sampling the blogosphere to see how people are reacting to Ms. Clinton's controversial remarks. As an Obama supporter who follows the campaign closely, I see this as just the latest in a long string of calculated, outrageous tactics Sen. Clinton has employed. Keith Olbermann's special comment this evening was harsh but, as he pointed out, we've already forgiven many previous offenses. Whatever the results of this episode, I hope things work out well for America as we decide between an old view of the world rooted in the 1940's and 50's and a new one that sheds many of the prejudices my generation grew up with. Can we do it? You be we can. Best wishes, Owen

Anonymous said...

I found tonight's coverage of Sen. Clinton's admittedly careless mentioning of the assassination of RFK in explaining that it is not at all unusual for campaigns to drag into June, despicable! I am primarily referring to Chris Matthews and Keith Olbermann. My teenage grandchildren would have no difficulty whatsoever understanding that Senator Clinton was referring only to the timeline of long campaign and certainly not wishing any harm to fall on anyone. However, these two supposedly learned gentlemen (?) jumped at the chance to sensationalize her comments on a slow news day in hopes of finally fulfilling their wish to see the Senator's campaign come to a conclusion.

I find these two ego-maniacs despicable. They continually fall back on "freedom of the press" to destroy any public figure who dares to disagree with their philosophies with immunity. I wonder where these two sad excuses of humanity who self-righteously claim to be such great patriots were when I was serving two tours of duty in defense of this Great Nation in Vietnam. Matthews I know took the typical cowards' way out and found himself conveniently in the Peace Corp. I suspect Olbermann somehow took the Chaney route with deferments.

The assassinations of JFK, RFK, and Martin Luther King remain among the most horrific memories of my lifetime for me and my family. The shock of the recent news of Senator Kennedy's hangs heavy over my household this very moment. But for Matthews and Olbermann to jump on careless talk and imply that Senator Clinton was wishing some harm would come to Senator Obama is unforgivable.

I'm sure there is great joy around the offices of MSNBC this evening. Hillary and Bill are dead at the hands of MSNBC! I sincerely hope that that your management and staff don't live to regret costing the Democratic Party the White House at the very time of this Nation's greatest need.

Now where is that remote?

C-L-I-C-K !!!!!!

Karen Angella said...

Certain words just should not be thrown about lightly
It's funny; I was one of those people who was rooting for Hilary in the beginning. I resented the implications from friends, acquaintances, etc. who said that I should have been in Obama's camp because I am black, and as a black person, if I didn't support Obama then it just goes to show that I was still mentally enslaved, etc. etc. etc.

In reality, Hilary seemed to be the candidate with the most experience at that time. Also, I had bought into the idea that she would have had a better chance against McCain and I wanted to see the Republicans out of power as soon as possible (Nothing against them and I am not an American so I can't even vote...I just think it's time for a new era, new approach and new ideas).

But since December Hilary has just been ruining her own image. Talk about needing advisors to edit your public speeches! She has a serious case of Foot-in-Mouth Syndrome. And whatever was going through her head when she used the "A" word, it doesn't really matter, does it? It's sparked the idea in someone's head, somewhere, that this would be a plausible solution to trumping the competitor. That is why, as people in the public eye (and yes, even teens and kids who post on blogs count), we need to WATCH WHAT WE SAY/WRITE about other people. Even if we don't mean it in a literal way, even if we think it is harmless, there are impressionable people (kids, socially deviant people, or just plain psychos) out there who could get the wrong impression and act upon our words. Sad but true.

libhom said...

Your anonymous troll is so creepy. Clinton made a thinly veiled threat to assassinate a political opponent, and that racist nutcase acted like it is the media that are overreacting.

Oregonian37 said...

I think I'm actually complimented that I got my first, or second troll ever.:)

As I recently told a friend, if this had been an isolated incident, I'm not sure I would be so concerned, but it isn't. This has been a running theme for several months, on the part of Clinton. Do I honestly think that Clinton is advocating offing Obama? I'm not ready to thing that ill of anyone. However, fully giving the benefit of the doubt, for someone who wants to be the leader of the "free" world, and answer that phone at 3 a.m., carelessness and not thinking before speaking (not to mention ignoring the advice of her staff), is not an option.

brenda said...

I do a lot of reading, and Hillary does have a record of saying things she shouldnt. We all make mistakes, but when your running for President what you say makes an impression, whether it's good, or bad. We can't afford any more bad. Look at the mess we're in now. Government spending is outrageous. It will take years to get out of the slump we're in. I wonder what the percentage of homeless is now.

Chuck Butcher said...

Look for it to soon be Obama's fault, no really.

Anonymous said...

I just want to know what the undecided Superdelegates are waiting on. (Their capes?) Hillary should never be V.P. Look at how dangerous she is!!! If they don't hurry up and boot her out, she will be the one pulling the trigger!!!!!

brenda said...

LOL..I'm not so sure it could get much more dangerous than what we have in office right now. "Trigger Happy Republicans" Thats the real truth. Hillary isnt my favorite person, but if it were between her and McCain, of course she would get my vote. I just regret that John Edwards isnt still in the running.